A title alone doesn’t tell you which disc you own
A list of titles tells you that you have a film, but not which disc is in your hand. The same work can exist as a theatrical cut and a director’s cut, a local release and an import, a first pressing and a remastered reissue. Each may differ in subtitle languages, commentary, aspect ratio and running time. When you later wonder which copy had the subtitles you need, the title alone can’t answer.
The point of noting editions isn’t to price a collection. It’s to know which disc to take down when you want to rewatch, whether a friend’s player will run it, and whether you’ve just bought a second copy of something you already own. So rather than filling in every field, keep writing down the few details you’ll actually look for again.
What to check first on the back of the case and on the disc
The bottom of the back cover usually gathers running time, aspect ratio, audio formats, subtitle languages, number of discs and region code into a small table. The spine often carries the publisher’s catalogue number. That number is the shortest way to tell different editions of the same title apart, so if you have time for only one detail, write that one down. Text printed on the disc or etched around its inner ring can vary between production runs of the same edition; note it only when you need fine comparisons.
Things outside the case itself, such as an obi strip, a booklet, postcards or a slipcover, are the first to disappear over the years. A single line listing what came in the box lets you tell later whether something is missing or was never there. If you take a photo, a shot of the specification table and the contents laid out together is more useful as a record than the front cover.
Edition: local release, remastered reissue (not the first release)
Catalogue number: copied exactly as printed on the spine
Specs: 2.39:1, Korean and English subtitles, feature disc plus one bonus disc
Contents: slipcover, one booklet. There was never a postcard
Region codes and video systems decide whether it will play
DVDs carry region codes. The United States and Canada are region 1; Europe and Japan are region 2; South Korea and much of East and Southeast Asia are region 3. Discs without a restriction are marked 0 or ALL. Blu-ray uses three regions, A, B and C: the Americas, Japan and South Korea share region A, while most of Europe is region B. That is why an import DVD may refuse to play on a local player while the Blu-ray of the same edition works. Most 4K UHD Blu-rays are released region-free, but a standard Blu-ray packed in the same box may still be region-locked.
For VHS, and for DVDs too, check the video system. North America, Japan and South Korea used NTSC, while most of Europe used PAL, so a tape bought in Europe may not play properly on a deck from an NTSC country. Write it briefly, such as “DVD region 2 · PAL,” and note whether you actually played it on your own equipment. Labels and real playback don’t always agree, so keeping what you tested apart from what the case says saves confusion when you lend it out.
Describe condition by what you saw, not by a grade
Condition notes matter most for second-hand discs and tapes. Instead of a broad verdict like “good condition,” write down what you saw. For a disc, note where the scratches are on the playing side, whether playback actually skipped, and whether the hub that holds the disc is broken. If a scratched disc played cleanly from start to finish, that fact matters more than the scratch.
VHS tapes change with storage. Note whether you saw white spots on the tape, whether the picture wobbled or the sound dragged on the first play, and whether it settled after a rewind. Much advice says a tape kept somewhere damp should rest somewhere dry for a while before playing, but for a precious tape it is safer to ask a restoration service first than to risk your deck. In the record itself, write only what you did and what happened afterwards.
- Disc surface or tape: the visible flaws and where they are
- Playback: whether it played to the end, and any sections that skipped
- Case and contents: damage, anything missing, anything that was never there
Edition differences matter when they connect to your reviews
If you own a director’s cut or an extended edition, link what differed from the version you saw in the cinema to your review. If one added scene changed how you saw a character, note it with a clue you can find again, like “the conversation added after the restaurant scene,” rather than a timestamp. When you aren’t sure what changed, don’t just repeat a label like “uncut”; write the running time from the case alongside the differences you confirmed yourself.
Subtitle translations can also differ between editions. If a line rendered differently changed your impression, say which disc gave you that thought: “in the reissue’s subtitles it sounded shorter and firmer.” There is no need to copy long subtitle passages. Keeping facts about the edition apart from your reading lets you compare, on a later watch of another edition, what came from the work and what came from the disc.
In Yeoun, keep the shelf shape and the record apart
When you add a film or series to Yeoun, choosing VHS, cassette, DVD or Blu-ray under “Kept as” puts it on the shelf in that shape. That choice sets how it looks in your library; it doesn’t attach edition details such as catalogue numbers or region codes. You can set your own rule instead: short edition labels like “Blu-ray A,” “remaster” or “import” go in “Tags,” and full specs and condition go in the first paragraph of a review.
If you own two editions of the same work, leave a separate review for each inside the one work and say on the first line which disc you watched. If the copy you own differs from the one you watched, for example because you saw it in a cinema or on a streaming service, note that too. You don’t need to fill in everything at once. Add a line each time you take a disc down, and the list will grow closer to the real shelf.
Try this today
- Write down the catalogue number from the spine and the number of discs first.
- Note the region code for DVD and Blu-ray, NTSC or PAL for VHS, and keep the actual playback result separately.
- Describe condition by the flaws you saw and how it played, not by “good.”
Found an error, or need help? Let us know through contact & corrections. You can also read how we write the guides.