Record collecting

Keeping the history of a single record

The same album is a different object in every country, decade and pressing. How to note catalogue numbers, condition grades and care history so you can check your record collection again.

Yeoun Guides · 8 min read
Published · Updated

An album and a release are different records

An album is a set of songs; the LP or CD in your hand is one release of it. The same album comes out many times, in different countries, decades and formats. The track order may change, bonus tracks may appear, and a reissue may be remastered. Your review can be about the album, but your collection record should point to the one copy on your shelf.

So a collection record asks “which release?” right after “which album?” Start by separating the year the album first came out from the year this copy was released. For a recent vinyl reissue of an old album, writing both years separately lets you answer later whether this was the original release.

One catalogue number separates one release from another

The first detail to write down is the catalogue number, the label’s own code for the release. On an LP it is usually on the spine, the back or the label; on a CD it is often on the spine and at the bottom of the back. Different releases of the same album normally have different catalogue numbers, so this number alone makes it easy to find the same release again on music databases or in shop listings. Add the barcode if there is one, though older records often have none.

For finer distinctions, look at the matrix number. On an LP it is etched in the blank band between the grooves and the label; on a CD it is in the clear ring around the centre hole. It can differ within one catalogue number depending on when and where the copy was pressed. If it is hard to read, tilt the record under a light, and leave any uncertain characters as “?”. A number filled in by guesswork will send you to the wrong release later.

A fictional LP reissue made for this guide, “Time by the Window”

Album: first released long ago / this copy is a recent reissue

Catalogue number: copied exactly as printed on the spine

Matrix: side A read in full; the last two characters on side B left as “??”

Contents: one inner sleeve, no lyric sheet, download code already used

Grade the record and the sleeve separately

The second-hand market commonly uses grades running from M (Mint, essentially perfect), NM (Near Mint), VG+ (signs of use but plays with little trouble) and VG (audible noise but still listenable) down to G and P. Sellers apply them a little differently, so a grade alone won’t tell you later what you based it on. Add one line of evidence next to it, such as “small skip near the start of side B, track one.”

Assess the record and the sleeve apart. For the sleeve, look at corner wear, creases, ring wear and split seams. For the record, keep what you saw apart from what you heard. Visible scuffs may make no noise, and a clean-looking record can still crackle. If you haven’t played it yet, say so: “visually VG+, not yet played.” Treat CDs and cassettes the same way, separating the disc or tape from the case and inserts.

  1. Record: write down how it looks and how it sounds, separately.
  2. Sleeve or case: note wear, creases, ring wear and damage.
  3. Contents: record inner sleeves, lyric sheets, obi strips and posters as they were when you got it.

Cleaning and playback setup become part of the history

If you cleaned a record or replaced its inner sleeve, note the date and the method briefly. Writing down whether the noise dropped or stayed the same gives you something to go on the next time you clean another record. Some people also note when they last played a cassette all the way through, since tape left wound for a long time can stretch. These notes don’t need to be long. One line at a time shows how the record has been looked after.

Write your impression of the sound together with the playback setup. The same record may sound different after you change a stylus or cartridge, or through other speakers. A note like “first listen after replacing the stylus” keeps you from mistaking a change in your setup for a change in the record. The point isn’t to rank equipment, but to record the conditions under which you made a judgement.

Keep the releases you want apart from the ones you own

As a collection grows, you start wanting to check in a shop whether you already have a release. With catalogue numbers in your list, you can tell at once when you see a different release of the same album. Keep wanted releases on a separate shelf from owned ones, and write one line on why you want each. A clear reason, such as “the cover printing of the first release” or “the edition with bonus tracks,” makes it less likely you’ll buy a similar but different copy on impulse.

In purchase notes, record when and where you found it, but keep anything you don’t want to share, like the price, in notes only you can see. For a record you were given, the memory of the first day you played it tends to last longer than who it came from.

Organising records release by release in Yeoun

When you add a record to Yeoun, choosing LP, CD or cassette under “Kept as” puts it on the shelf in that shape. The choice only sets its look; release details are not attached automatically. If you own two releases of the same album, add the work twice and tell them apart with a note after the title, like “(vinyl reissue),” or with release details in “Tags.”

Put the catalogue number, the grade and its evidence, and the care history in the first paragraph of a review, and write about the music below it. For releases you want, make a separate shelf such as “Wanted” so they never mix with the records you own. Before sharing your library, get into the habit of separating reviews you will show from private notes like price or where you bought it.

Try this today

  1. Write the album’s original year and this copy’s release year separately.
  2. Start with the catalogue number; add the matrix number only with the characters you can read for certain.
  3. Grade the record and the sleeve separately, and add one line of evidence.

Found an error, or need help? Let us know through contact & corrections. You can also read how we write the guides.

Your own library

What stayed with you, on your own shelf.

Open my library